SimpleShrink vs CleanMy®Phone (Formerly Gemini Photos): An Honest Comparison
MacPaw's CleanMy®Phone sorts your photos with AI and keeps duplicates behind a subscription. SimpleShrink shrinks videos, Live Photos, and screenshots. Compared.
By the SimpleShrink teamFacts checked 4 min read
The short version
CleanMy®Phone is MacPaw's photo cleaner, the app Gemini Photos became in 2024. It's polished, sorts your library into AI categories, and adds a phone health check, but duplicates, similar photos, Live Photo conversion, and video compression all need a subscription ($7.99 a month or $36.99 a year in the US). SimpleShrink finds duplicates and junk for free, one swipe at a time, and its Pro plan ($24.99 a year) shrinks videos, trims recordings, turns Live Photos into stills, and re-saves screenshots, then measures what you got back. Choose CleanMy®Phone for organizing; choose SimpleShrink for getting the most space back without deleting memories.
If you used Gemini Photos, you already know CleanMy®Phone. MacPaw, the company behind CleanMyMac, replaced Gemini with it in March 2024 on the same App Store listing. It now averages 4.6 stars from about 23,000 ratings in the US.
SimpleShrink and CleanMy®Phone both start from your photo library, but they're built for different goals. Here's the comparison.
At a glance
| Feature | ||
|---|---|---|
| Duplicates and similar photos | Yes, free to swipe through; in bulk with Pro | Subscription only |
| Blurry and black shots | Yes, free to swipe through | Blurred photos, subscription only |
| Large videos and screenshots | Yes, free | Yes, free |
| Video compression | Yes, Pro | Yes, subscription |
| Trim long videos | Yes, Pro | Not advertised |
| Live Photos to stills | Yes, Pro | Yes, subscription |
| Screenshot re-save | Yes, Pro | Not advertised |
| Best shot of each burst | Yes, free | Not advertised |
| AI categories (people, pets, travel) | No | Yes, subscription |
| Contacts and email cleanup | No | Yes |
| Big files in the Files app | Yes, free | Not advertised |
| Measures the space you got back | Yes, before and after | Storage overview, no before-and-after figure |
| Paid plans (US) | $4.99/week or $24.99/year | $7.99/month or $36.99/year after a 3-day trial |
| Privacy label | Data Not Collected | Identifiers and usage data used to track you |
| Requires | iOS 17, iPhone | iOS 17, iPhone and iPad |
What CleanMy®Phone does well
MacPaw makes careful, good-looking software, and CleanMy®Phone shows it:
- Organize sorts your library into AI categories like Travel, People, Pets, Food, and Documents, which is genuinely useful if your camera roll is chaos.
- Health gives your phone a score, a security check, storage analytics, and a speed test, free for everyone.
- Contacts and email: merge duplicate contacts and unsubscribe from newsletters.
- It works on iPhone and iPad, and it's included in Setapp if you already subscribe.
What's free, and what isn't
This is where the two apps differ most.
CleanMy®Phone's free version covers the Largest Videos and Screenshots categories, the Other category in Organize, and the Health module, according to MacPaw's own support page. The features most people install a cleaner for, finding duplicates and similar photos, sit behind the subscription, along with blurred photos, Live Photo conversion, and video compression.
In SimpleShrink, finding duplicates is free. Swipe to clean puts every likely delete in front of you, biggest first: extra copies (the best one always stays), blurry and black shots, receipts, documents, and old screenshots. Swipe left to delete, right to keep, with undo, and everything you chose is deleted together at the end. The best shot of each burst, the Files cleanup, and every step-by-step guide are free too.
Pro is for the heavy lifting: shrinking and trimming videos, Live Photos to stills, screenshot re-saves, and clearing everything in one tap.
Shrinking, not just sorting
CleanMy®Phone added video compression and Live Photo conversion in 2025, and both are worth having. SimpleShrink takes the same idea further:
- Trim, then shrink. Long recordings can be cut to the part you want before they're compressed.
- Screenshots re-saved. iPhone screenshots are PNG files. SimpleShrink re-saves them as smaller HEIC copies with the same pixels, which adds up fast if you keep thousands.
- Details kept. Every shrunk video and converted Live Photo keeps its date, location, favorite status, and album, and SimpleShrink checks each one afterwards.
If you're wondering how much Live Photos really cost you, our Live Photos storage guide breaks it down.
Price
CleanMy®Phone costs $7.99 a month or $36.99 a year on the US App Store, after a 3-day trial that renews automatically. MacPaw also sells a lifetime option, though its terms say it doesn't include major upgrades or new features released after you buy.
SimpleShrink Pro is $24.99 a year, less than CleanMy®Phone's yearly plan, or $4.99 for a single week if you just need one big cleanup. There's no trial to cancel, because the free scan already shows how much Pro would save on your phone.
Privacy
Both apps process your photos on the device. CleanMy®Phone's App Store label lists identifiers and usage data as "Data Used to Track You". SimpleShrink has no analytics, no ads, and no network connections, so its label is Data Not Collected.
Which should you choose?
Choose CleanMy®Phone if you want your library organized into categories, you use an iPad too, or you already have Setapp.
Choose SimpleShrink if you want duplicates found without a subscription, if your space is mostly videos and Live Photos you'd rather keep, or if you want a measured before-and-after instead of an estimate.
Frequently asked questions
What happened to Gemini Photos?
MacPaw replaced Gemini Photos with CleanMy®Phone on March 5, 2024. It's the same App Store listing, existing users were moved over automatically, and the old app can't be restored. Gemini subscribers kept their original price.
Is CleanMy®Phone free?
Partly. The free version covers the Largest Videos and Screenshots categories, the Other category in Organize, and the Health module. Duplicates, similar and blurry photos, Live Photo conversion, video compression, and the AI categories need a subscription.
How much does CleanMy®Phone cost?
On the US App Store in November 2026, it's $7.99 a month or $36.99 a year, with a 3-day free trial that renews automatically. MacPaw also offers a one-time lifetime purchase, which doesn't include major new features released later.
Can SimpleShrink organize my photos into albums or categories?
No. SimpleShrink is built for one job: getting your space back. If you want your library sorted into people, pets, travel, and documents, CleanMy®Phone's Organize feature does that and SimpleShrink doesn't.
Can either app clear System Data or junk files?
No. iOS doesn't let any App Store app clear System Data, other apps' caches, or "junk". MacPaw says the same in its replies to reviews. See why System Data gets so large for what actually helps.
How we checked
Everything here about CleanMy®Phone comes from its App Store listing, its developer's own pages, or the reporting linked below, as of November 11, 2026. Prices and features change, and the App Store shows different offers to different people, so check the listing before you buy. Spotted something out of date? Tell us and we'll fix it.
- CleanMy®Phone: Cleanup Storage on the US App Store (listing, in-app purchases, privacy label, version history)
- MacPaw: Introducing CleanMy®Phone (March 2024)
- MacPaw support: Gemini Photos to CleanMy®Phone
- MacPaw support: free and premium features
- MacPaw: CleanMy®Phone update with video compression and Health (June 2025)
- CleanMy®Phone Terms of Use
- TechCrunch: MacPaw's new app helps you remove redundant photos (March 2024)